Security Guarantees
Who will play the crucial role in providing security guarantees to Ukraine amid tensions with Russia?
According to Marc Polymeropoulos, the European powers will play the decisive role in providing security guarantees to Ukraine. He notes that President Zelensky feels betrayed, and while US leadership remains important, the responsibility will ultimately rest with European nations to ensure Ukraine can continue its struggle against Russia. Polymeropoulos references a meeting in Paris and suggests that European coordination is essential for Ukraine's ongoing defense. This indicates a shift in security dynamics where European nations must take greater ownership of supporting Ukraine, particularly as questions arise about the consistency of US involvement in the conflict.
Watch clip answer (00:26m)
MSNBC
02:31 - 02:58
What does Boris Johnson believe is necessary for effectively deterring Russian aggression against Ukraine?
Boris Johnson emphasizes that a US security guarantee is essential for effectively deterring Russia from attacking Ukraine again. While he indicates willingness to consider committing British forces on the ground alongside other nations if there is a lasting peace agreement, he stresses that this European effort must be backed by American support. Johnson specifically states that 'a US Backstop' is necessary because only a US Security guarantee can provide the level of deterrence needed against Russian aggression. This highlights his view that European security efforts, even with British participation, require American backing to be truly effective in protecting Ukraine from future Russian threats.
Watch clip answer (00:23m)
WION
02:44 - 03:07
What is Ukraine's stance on security guarantees and how are European leaders responding?
Kyiv is firmly rejecting conditions that would leave Ukraine vulnerable, warning that without proper security guarantees, Russia could launch another invasion. This concern is shared by European leaders, particularly British officials who have expressed readiness to commit ground forces alongside others if a lasting peace agreement is reached. However, British leadership emphasizes that a US backstop is essential, stating that American security guarantees are 'the only way to effectively deter Russia from attacking Ukraine again.' This position underscores the widespread belief that despite European willingness to contribute militarily, US involvement remains critical for credible deterrence against future Russian aggression.
Watch clip answer (00:34m)
WION
02:33 - 03:07
What are the key elements needed for a permanent end to the war in Ukraine?
According to National Security Advisor Mike Walz, achieving a permanent end to the war in Ukraine—not just a temporary cessation of hostilities as seen in the past—requires addressing several fundamental aspects. Two critical elements will inevitably be part of negotiations: territorial discussions and security guarantees. These components are described as the "fundamental basics" that will undergird any meaningful peace talks. Walz emphasizes the practical reality that these difficult issues must be confronted directly to establish a lasting resolution rather than another temporary pause in the conflict.
Watch clip answer (00:30m)
CBS News
02:20 - 02:51
What is President Zelenskyy's position on US-Russia talks that exclude Ukraine?
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy has firmly rejected any outcome from talks between the United States and Russia that do not include Kyiv (Kiev). His stance comes in response to discussions held in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, where Ukrainian representatives were notably absent despite the talks concerning their nation's future. This rejection highlights a critical concern for Ukraine's leadership - being sidelined in diplomatic negotiations directly affecting their sovereignty and security. Zelenskyy's position raises important questions about what security guarantees Ukraine can realistically expect when excluded from conversations determining its fate.
Watch clip answer (00:22m)
WION
00:48 - 01:11
Why have Europe and Ukraine been sidelined from the US-Russia talks in Riyadh?
The US-Russia talks in Riyadh marked the first discussion between officials from both countries since the Ukraine conflict began in February 2022, but notably excluded Ukrainian and European representatives. This exclusion appears strategic, allowing the US and Russia to engage in direct dialogue about Ukraine's future without immediate input from the parties most directly affected. Ukrainian President Zelenskyy has expressed firm opposition to any outcomes determined without Kyiv's participation, highlighting the controversial nature of these talks. The sidelining suggests a potential shift in diplomatic approach, raising concerns about who ultimately determines Ukraine's security arrangements and territorial integrity in any potential resolution process.
Watch clip answer (00:11m)
WION
00:59 - 01:11