Legal Whistleblowing
Why did Denise Chung resign from her position at the U.S. Department of Justice?
Denise Chung, the Chief of the Criminal Division in the U.S. Attorney's office in Washington, D.C., resigned after refusing to compromise her ethical standards when pressured by the Trump Justice Department. She specifically refused to create misleading documentation about an investigation that would have facilitated what she viewed as the illegal seizure of banking records. This resignation represents another instance of principled departure from the Trump administration's Justice Department, where career officials faced ethical dilemmas when ordered to cross professional lines. Chung chose to step down rather than put a lie in writing that would enable actions she believed were unlawful.
Watch clip answer (00:33m)
MSNBC
02:12 - 02:45
Why did prosecutor Denise Chung resign from the Justice Department?
Denise Chung, a career federal prosecutor with 24 years of experience, resigned after refusing to facilitate what she viewed as an illegal seizure of banking records. She was pressured to write a letter claiming there was probable cause to seize certain bank accounts, but she maintained there was insufficient evidence to support such action. When Chung explained her legal concerns and refused to cross this ethical line, her resignation was requested. In her resignation letter, Chung detailed how she was accused of "wasting five hours" trying to get what she and the FBI wanted rather than what her superiors demanded. Her principled stand represents part of a broader pattern, becoming the eighth resignation on principle from Trump's Justice Department in just one week.
Watch clip answer (02:19m)
MSNBC
02:12 - 04:31
What constitutional concerns is Trump raising about the Whistleblower Protection Act?
Trump is arguing that the Whistleblower Protection Act of 1989 is unconstitutional because it limits presidential power to remove agency heads. He contends this creates significant separation of powers issues, as the Constitution allegedly grants presidents broad authority to remove officials who execute executive power alongside the president. The law restricts removal to cases of inefficiency, neglect of duty, or malfeasance in office. Trump's argument centers on accountability - the president needs authority over subordinates so the public can properly hold the administration accountable for government performance. This case could have implications for independent agencies and whistleblower protections.
Watch clip answer (00:56m)
CBS News
01:12 - 02:08
What is the current status of Hampton Dellinger's job as head of the Office of Special Counsel?
Hampton Dellinger has successfully maintained his position despite being fired by Trump. After his termination on a Friday night, Dellinger sued on Monday morning and immediately secured legal protection. A federal judge issued a temporary restraining order blocking Trump from firing him, which will remain in place until at least February 26th. This order prevents Trump's replacement from taking office as acting special counsel. Currently, Dellinger remains in office with full access to his workplace while the Supreme Court considers the broader constitutional questions about presidential power to remove agency heads.
Watch clip answer (00:59m)
CBS News
02:09 - 03:09
Why is Donald Trump appealing to the Supreme Court regarding Hampton Dellinger?
Donald Trump is appealing to the Supreme Court to overturn a lower court order that blocked his administration's firing of Hampton Dellinger, the head of the Office of Special Counsel which protects whistleblowers. Dellinger was appointed by President Biden in 2023 for a five-year term but was fired by the Trump administration in February. The case centers on whether the president has authority to dismiss the head of this independent agency. Dellinger claims his removal violates legal provisions that specify termination can only occur on strict performance-related grounds. The Supreme Court's decision could significantly impact separation of powers and future executive authority over federal appointments.
Watch clip answer (00:39m)CBS News
00:05 - 00:44
What is the current status of Hampton Dellinger's job after his attempted dismissal by the Trump administration?
Dellinger has successfully challenged his firing at every step so far. After being dismissed on a Friday night, he promptly filed a lawsuit the following Monday morning. A federal judge immediately issued a brief stay, followed by a longer temporary order blocking Trump from terminating his employment. The case now awaits a Supreme Court decision on the broader implications for presidential authority over agency positions. Currently, due to these legal interventions, Dellinger remains in his position while the legal battle continues through the courts.
Watch clip answer (00:25m)
CBS News
02:09 - 02:34